Back Share
Challenges

Sustainability (including social and environmental sustainability): AI could hamper, not foster, progress on SDGs

SDGs sustainability

*"Issue: *Current roadmaps for development and deployment of A/IS are not aligned with or guided by their impact in the most important challenges of humanity, defined in the seventeen United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which collectively aspire to create a more equal world of prosperity, peace, planet protection, and human dignityfor all people.4

## BackgroundSDGs promoting prosperity, peace, planet protection, human dignity The human right to be valued and treated with respect because of one's personhood. , and respect for human rights of all, apply to HIC and LMIC alike. Yet ensuring that the benefits of A/IS will accrue to humanity as a whole, leaving “no one behind”, requires an ethical commitment to global citizenship and well-being, and a conscious effort to counter the nature of the tech economy, with its tendency to concentrate wealth within high income populations. Implementation of the SDGs should benefit excluded sectors of society in every country, regardless of A/IS infrastructure.“The Road to Dignity The human right to be valued and treated with respect because of one's personhood. by 2030” document of the UN Secretary General reports on resources and methods for implementing the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and emphasizes the importance of science, technology, and innovation for a sustainable future.5 The UN Secretary General posits that:“A sustainable future will require that we act now to phase out unsustainable technologies and to invest in innovation and in the development of clean and sound technologies for sustainable development. We must ensure that they are fairly priced, broadly disseminated and fairly absorbed, including to and by developing countries.” (para. 120)A/IS are among the technologies that can play an important role in the solution of the deep social problems plaguing our global civilization, contributing to the transformation of society away from an unsustainable, unequal socioeconomic system, towards one that realizes the vision of universal human dignity The human right to be valued and treated with respect because of one's personhood. , peace, and prosperity.However, with all the potential benefits ofA/IS, there are also risks. For example, givenA/IS technology’s immense power needs, without new sources of sustainable energy harnessed to power A/IS in the future, there is a risk that it will increase fossil fuel use and have a negative impact on the environment and the climate.While 45% of the world’s population is not connected to the internet, they are not necessarily excluded from A/IS’ potential benefits: in LMIC mobile networks can provide data for A/IS applications. However, only those connected are likely to benefit from the income-producing potential of internet technologies. In 2017, internet penetration in HIC left behind certain portions of the population often in rural or remote areas; 12% of U.S. residents and 20% of residents across Europe were unable to access the internet. In Asia with its concentration of LMIC, 52% of the population, on average, had no access, a statistic skewed by the large population of China, where internet penetration reached 45% of the population. In numerous other countries in the region, 99% of residents had no access. This nearly total exclusion also exists in several countries in Africa, where the overall internet penetration is only 35%: 2 of every 3 residents in Africa have no access.6 Those with no internet access also do not generate data needed to “train” A/IS, and are thereby excluded from benefits of the technology, the development of which risks systematic discriminatory bias, particularly against people from minority populations, and those living in rural areas, or in low-income countries. As a comparison, one study estimated that “in the US, just one home automation product can generate a data point every six seconds.”7 In Mozambique, where about 90% of the population lack internet access, “the average household generates zero digital data points.”8 With mobile phones generating much of the data needed for developing A/IS applications in LMIC, unequal phone ownership may build in bias. For example, there is a risk of discrimination against women, who across LMIC are 14% less likely than men to own a mobile phone, and in South Asia where 38% are less likely to own a mobile phone.9

## RecommendationsThe current range of A/IS applications in sectors crucial to the SDGs, and to excluded populations everywhere, should be studied, with the strengths, weaknesses, and potential of the most significant recent applications analyzed, and the best ones developed at scale. Specific objectives to consider include:

Overarching Principles Respect for persons
Principles Respect for persons
Sources IEEE
Title Sustainability (including social and environmental sustainability): AI could hamper, not foster, progress on SDGs